The winds of change may be brewing within the Chinese stock market, often referred to as A-shares, as a seismic shift seems imminentRecently, the market experienced its third "gravestone doji" pattern in just over a year — a grim indicator that typically signals indecision among tradersMore significant, however, was the adjustment of the nation's monetary policy description from a "prudent" approach to a stance defined as "moderately accommodative." Many traders and analysts may have overlooked the profound implications of this policy shiftIn the realm of stock trading, capital flow plays a crucial role; as more participants enter the market, stock prices tend to rise in a classic case of "a rising tide lifts all boats." This movement in the financial landscape is often dictated by monetary policy, which sets the underlying tone for market sentimentHistorical precedents, such as Japan’s Abenomics over a decade ago and the U.S

Advertisements

Federal Reserve's quantitative easing strategies implemented four years back, have demonstrated the face of a bull market when monetary policies favor liquidity.

With the recent loosening of monetary policy, a bear market in A-shares appears increasingly improbableAnalysts speculate that the next year or two may present minimal risks, prompting recommendations for investors to bide their time in the marketsAfter enduring a prolonged bearish environment, many investors eagerly anticipate a version of China's infinite quantitative easing (QE). However, it is imperative to maintain a level-headed perspective even amidst optimistic expectationsThe current liquidity measures predominantly aim to revitalize the real estate sector and stimulate consumer spending to propel economic recoverySolid companies with sound fundamentals may see valuation rebounds as their performance improves, but this does not automatically translate into explosive market rallies

Advertisements

As seen in the past week, a surge due to positive news was swiftly followed by a significant drop, highlighting the market's volatility and the fragility of investor sentiment.

The central goal of moderately accommodative monetary policy is to invigorate the economy and financial marketsBy shifting expectations away from deflation and towards inflation, this approach raises the risk appetite among investors, encouraging them to withdraw cash from banksTake Argentina, for instance, where hyperinflation over five years reached nearly 100 timesHolding onto cash during this period would have resulted in a staggering 99% loss in purchasing power; conversely, the Argentine stock market soared by 100 timesIn essence, stock markets often serve as a refuge against inflation, leading to a significant influx of capitalWhile this is an extreme example, it illuminates a central lesson: if the expectation in our markets shifts from deflation to inflation, asset prices generally increase, while cash gradually loses value — a trend that is fundamentally irreversible.

The impending waves of liquidity promise a decreasing benchmark interest rate

Advertisements

In the present interest rate climate, traditional savings products like bank deposits and government bonds are becoming less appealingEven gold is losing its edge as a store of value, and apart from prime real estate locations, property has limited upsideAt this juncture, no asset holds a candle to quality stocks with high dividend yieldsThe recent swift movements in the market demonstrated that dividend-paying stocks are notably stable, a direct reaction to the confirmation of expansive monetary policyIn such an environment, it becomes essential to weigh the contrast in performance between corporate profit growth and GDP expansion against the dividends offered by stable stocksWhile dreams may lean towards the former, the reality stands firmly with the latterThis explains why, despite anticipating that dividend stocks may peak shortly, we chose not to reduce our overall dividend exposure in the first half of the year, opting instead for tactical reallocations while maintaining a robust position in dividend stocks, which are poised to thrive in a low-interest landscape.

Recently, notable changes occurred when Changjiang Electric Power was removed from the CSI Dividend index

• Coal Stocks: Are We in a Bubble?
• A Look at Fund Managers' Q4 Strategies
• German Companies Postpone Borrowing
• Digital & Green Skills: The New Competitive Edge
• Nikkei ETF: A Graveyard for Retail Investors

Such gestures affirm the index's rigorous standards regarding dividend yield, illustrating that even big names can fall from grace if their dividend rates declineThis action contrasts sharply with the more bullish, often speculative movements seen in the 50-IndexThe current average dividend yield following this adjustment stands at an impressive 5.31%, significantly surpassing the previous average yield of 2.89%. The adjustments are both reasonable and stringent, ensuring that the index maintains a commendable dividend levelWith an accumulated market value of around 60 billion, the impact from Changjiang Electric's removal — holding just over 1% of the dividend index — may impose a potential sell-off pressure of 600-700 million, but this is unlikely to disrupt day-to-day trading volumeThis serves as a profound reminder that some previously touted blue-chip stocks may no longer present worthy opportunities for yield chasing

This development is likely to incite debates about the validity of dividends, as detractors often argue that dividends without substantial capital appreciation are worthless.

The impact of dividends on stock prices is evident when analyzing the divergent trajectories between dividend ETFs under different scenariosFirstly, we must clarify the mechanics of share exclusion and adjustmentExclusion refers to stock price changes post-dividend, while share adjustment can be split into two categories: pre-adjusted and post-adjusted pricesPre-adjusted prices reduce historical prices based on current values, while post-adjusted prices apply historical pricing as a base to elevate current valuationsThe latter incorporates dividends more effectively into yield calculations, presenting a more accurate representation of total returnsIn scenarios involving dividend exclusion, the divergence becomes stark; for instance, in the last ten years, dividend ETFs have displayed minimal price growth, leading to investor losses

However, when considering post-adjusted returns, it becomes clear that these funds represent substantial growth, recording a 90% increase since early 2016.

This discrepancy hinges on dividend payouts; dividend ETFs consistently distribute significant profits, dynamically shifting their indexing based on constituent companies’ yieldsSuch a strategy sharply contrasts with the standard practice of merely evaluating market cap and simple price appreciationConsequently, dividend indices sustain elevated yield levels, enabling ETFs that track them to deliver consistent returns for investorsIn the context of A-share regulations regarding dividend exclusion, as long as stock prices remain stable, these dividend earnings are essentially a bonus for investorsMoreover, the constituent stocks in the dividend index mainly comprise stable enterprises with robust shareholder returns, which, over recent years, have witnessed valuation recoveries supporting stock price increases

Thus, the CSI Dividend index has grown to become a formidable benchmark for domestic indicesHowever, absent dividends, the post-exclusion trajectories could be likened to enduring low-yield debt instruments akin to banks.

In the previous bullish market cycle, we maintained that the dividend yield of our stock portfolio should never drop below the yield of money market fundsThis approach effectively safeguarded against losses, even if holdings experienced stagnation over long periodsHowever, with the ongoing decline in benchmark interest rates, prevalent money market funds are offering annual yields around 1.5%, while ten-year government bonds and long-term bank deposits have slipped below 2%. As such, fixed income now emerges as a less effective allocation strategyI contend that current portfolio dividend yields should aim for alignment with the dividend index, targeting at least a 3%-4% yield — it ought not to trail Changjiang Electric's dividend yield, especially considering its recent omission from the index.

Nevertheless, we must reiterate that lauding specific holdings or indices does not equate to encouraging immediate purchases

Undoubtedly, when enthusiasm builds around a stock, it often has already increased in valueThe best strategy with dividend ETFs tends to involve waiting for optimal price points aligned with moving averagesFor instance, stocks such as Changjiang Electric, Ningbo Huaxin Expressway, and China Mobile were previously robust positions now residing at elevated levels, thus I do not advocate direct purchases at this timeDividend stocks may increase slowly, resulting in frustration for those entering at high prices, compelling most to sell prematurely, despite the awareness that future growth may persistDividend stocks embody a mindset of long-term growth, as the market hive mind occasionally neglects numerous sectors beyond the key dividend stocks, still presenting ample investment avenues across diverse sectors.

In an unpredictable market, bold investment choices become increasingly challenging

Following significant downturns, the prospect of renewed monetary easing and an uptick in liquidity may signal an abundant opportunity within A-sharesNevertheless, lingering hesitations become pronounced in the wake of prolonged suffering, engendering a loss of trust in the marketsJust as the ascent to 3400 appears elusive, the sentiment can often feel relegated to a depressive 2400. Regardless of A-shares' enchanting volatility, a reality remains: this market still includes quality core assets trading at 10x PE multiplesEven amid disarray, robust growth companies exist that provide stable returns without requiring further capital injectionsReflecting on the last bullish cycle, one could easily misinterpret the broader market signalsIn the dynamic, speculative world of tech stocks, it's often prudent to align oneself with firms in financially sound positions that leverage dividends and share repurchases.

Consistently fixating on price fluctuations in A-shares may lead to disillusionment, as tangible returns are what ultimately materialize in the investment journey